Blue Bell is absolutely the best store-bought ice cream I've ever had. I gave up on Haagen Dazs, Ben & Jerry's, or Blue Bunny since eating Blue Bell. I also like Talenti Gelato, Caramel Cookie Crunch is my favorite flavor. OP if you can you should try Blue Bell's Cookies and Cream, it is most definitely delicious IMO.
ive never seen any Blue Bell in any of the stores around me.
I keep forgetting that it is not widely available like other brands of ice cream such as Ben and Jerry's or Haagen Dazs. It's only been sold in stores in 2 cities of my home state for about 3 years now. According to the history page on Blue Bell's site, it's only sold in 26% of the nation's supermarkets (in 20 states).
For me, I don't care about brand it is. But I do have my favorite flavor. I love Rocky Road, Cookies and Cream, Reese, Pistacho, Vanilla, Birthday Cake, Egg Nog, and Christmas Cookies. I like Blue Bell Egg Nog and Christmas Cookies, during Christmas time and sooo delicious!
My favorite Blue Bell holiday flavor is Spiced Pumpkin Pecan, it tastes like frozen pumpkin pie that's been kicked up a notch.