Does it make much difference which game is better if they're both fun..? Reviews are a matter of opinion. I can't see SSM saying a Sony owned franchise sucks. Starhawk failed because of lack of marketing, support and an angry Warhawk crowd trashing it on the forums. When I came here for the first time someone told me not to waste my time on SH, for example.
But the other reviews of starhawk suck. They have terrible reasons on why it is a bad game. They base a lot of the score on the SP, when it a mp game!!! Ign had the best most accurate review in my opionion.