Looking for one myself, but I want it for live broadcasting. So no capture or edits. Juss straight to vid
You have to figure out exactly what you need first...I don't know how to (not interested) but I'm pretty sure you still need a capture device of some sort...
EDIT: I think the main difference is the software you'll be using, not the hardware...
The Hauppauge models look interesting.
A bit disappointed I'll have to switch from HDMI to component just to capture PS3 stuff. My gaming set up is complex enough so now I'll have to adjust some more stuff.
Also have to check the back of my gaming TV to see if it has another component input before buying anything. Been mounted on the wall so long I can't remember.
Right now I have a PC, PS1, PS2, PS3 slim, PSP and composite cables for NES/SNES hooked up to it. I think the PSP hook up is component so I may get lucky and use that port.
Only use my PSP now as a MP3 player for one of my cars that only has a cassette deck. It's old but still fun to drive.
Sorry, getting way off topic.