Thought the look of the old Ellie was better? Who cares if she looked like Ellen Page, shes not ugly (in most cases)
No I liked Ellen Page Ellie better. I'd star at Ellen Page all day, everyday.
Actually... Fact time
Naughty Dog originally, in the concept ideas, wanted her to be in her late teens, like 16-18. But they changed it, as a younger girl would have a more emotional appeal to the players and Joel, if anything were to happen to her. (NOT SAYING IT WILL)
They also changed it because Ellen Page threatened to sue.