Gameplay wise I think that Last of Us could be something new and refreshing, since we haven't had something difficult to the point where you have to plan your attack recently. But, Last of Us has to bring an amazing story full of twists and turns and lots of feels to try to be on par with Bioshock Infinite's story. Even though Infinite's gameplay wasn't amazing the story completely blew me away. The last Naughty Dog game with a truly great story was the Jak Trilogy so let's hope Naughty Dog brings that kind of ingenuity to this game.
I've got high hopes for it. But I'll wait till I get my hands on it.
@Hippo: Man I feel the same way. It's an amazing game, but after some much time and seeing the demos, you expect more. Honestly I think they had too much time. Allows for too many builds an changes. But, let's stick to TLoU.
I mean Bioshock Infinite is still an amazing game,I think they didn't add some of the footage shown from the demo because they probably couldn't,but again they let down a lot of customers so I really doubt that it would win GOTY really. Like the Boy of Silence,as Ken Levine said,walking security cameras,including they use sound as an weapon,in the game they ended up just standing in one freaking spot and didn't even use sound to locate you,but instead use their eyes (which by the way they're blind) to find you. Honestly the first Bioshock was much better in my opinion. Again I still love Infinite though,and even though it did disappoint me with a lot of things,I'm still happy I played the game.
If you want to read about what could've made Bioshock Infinite better,go here:
Really I think the only chance of it giving GOTY is with the DLC,but I'm really putting my bets on The Last of Us.