Refer to this thread for clarification:
Basically, do you think we would have been better off with a two weapon only system, like it was in the E3 trailer? It would be similar to Uncharted, as in Joel would drop his current weapon and take the newer weapon.
Having this system would also mean that you can disarm enemies.
That's a hard one to answer. I like the array of weapons given to you in the final product. But at the same time, disarming enemies would be really cool as well. I'd say that the system we got here is good enough as I'd rather keep all those weapons handy when versing a Bloaters and the like. I'm sure diarming enemies won't be as justifiable with only two weapons. But then again.... opinions
I also wasn't a fan of upgrading guns, most of them felt too useless at the start, and once they were fully upgraded, they became too good.
But that's just me... Only weapon I felt Joel and Ellie should always have handy is the Bow, everything else would have been better as a pickup in my opinion.