A Couple of questions, I have killed way over 10 crows and 10 gulls, but yet got a trophy for them. Looted them as well.
2nd, all the bad guys are dead, some of the trophies you have to do 10 rope kills and kill with a rifle, but if none spawn, how do you finish it?
You have to restart another playthrough. Enemies don't respawn in this game if you go back given you've killed them. Not sure what is up with the crows and gulls because if you kill and gut 10 you should have the trophy pop.
I had to do a second playthrough for Chatterbox. That is a nasty trophy especially given it's a hidden one besides.
I believe the pull downs with a rope arrow are 5 kills. I personally had trouble with the dodge trophy – Former Adventurer. I think that was 25 and I ended up getting that near the end of my second playthrough.
Some enemies do respawn if you go back, but you'll have much more luck with a second playthrough.
I'm going to start a new playthrough to get the Rope Pull, Dodge, Kill 2 with dropped dynamite and Chatterbox trophies. Wanted to play the first time without any hints from a walkthrough. No way you'll get all the single player trophies without it, though.
Just be careful with Chatterbox because the second discussion with Dr. Whitman is bugged. You are supposed to collect 50 salvage before upgrading your axe. Be sure to talk to him first before upgrading. I found personally that the second discussion was bugged and had to continue to try talking to him, collecting 10 more salvage, try again and so on. It took quite a few tries before he finally started talking.
If you google it you'll find that it's not uncommon and probably needs a patch.
However on videos and screenshots I have looked at it shows its wide open to get the latern.
Take a look.
It's the first part of the video.
On mine it is covered with ply wood and wont allow me to enter it at all.
Do you have the shotgun? You might need that to get past the plywood. I don't remember the specifics of that challenge and if I got it done the first time or if I had to fast track back to get it done.